Archives

Derail the ‘‘hate crimes’’ bandwagon!

Derail the ‘hate crimes’ bandwagon!

We’ll get to hate momentarily, but first a word about its consort — marriage. I’m glad to see that California’s Supreme Court is not above a bit of economic pump-priming to help bail out the Golden State in its hour of bankruptcy. The court’s decision on May 26 to uphold the voters’ ban last year on same-sex marriage will ensure that a torrent of money pours into California as the nonprofits and political action committees on both sides prime their bank balances for the next state initiative. Long term, it’s a shot in the arm for the tourist industry, too. Half a century down the road, long lines will be forming in the Castro for visitors to gawk through the window of some antique store at the wizened last same-sex couple legally married before the ban kicked in.

Of course, it also means month after unendurable month of gays whiningon TV about the horrors of not being able to “marry.” Ban all marriage,I say! If it’s a property issue, then write out a contract. There areplenty of simple legal instruments available.The victims’ lobby rules. Assuming child abusers manage to avoid “civilcommitment” (continued incarceration past the stipulated prisonsentence), Megan’s Law ensures that they will go on paying for theircrimes till the day they die. If Megan’s Law, why not “Madoff’s Law”?Put every person convicted of financial fraud on a computerized list,available for public inspection. Saddle them with endless prohibitions,like no living within 30 miles of a bank or an ATM.We’ve got the Matthew Shepard Act before Congress and far advanced onits journey into the statute book. This isn’t about equality. It’s aham-handed attempt to right injustice by establishing different legaltreatment for some classes of crime victims. America is well on its wayto making it illegal to say anything nasty about gays, Jews, blacks andwomen. “Hate speech,” far short of any direct incitement to violence,is on the edge of being criminalized, with the First Amendment gone theway of the dodo.At the end of April, the House of Representatives approved and sent onto the Senate a bill formally known as the Local Law Enforcement HateCrimes Prevention Act, backed by Obama’s White House. It classifies“hate crimes” as attacks based on a victim’s actual or perceived race,color, religion, national origin, gender, sexual orientation, genderidentity or disability.Now, there already is a 1960s federal statute on the books proscribinghate crimes based on race, color, religion or ethnic origin, butprosecutors could invoke this law only if the victim was engaged in a“federally protected activity” like going to school or praying inchurch. No more, if the Senate agrees with the House.Suppose two fellows in a bar see a man

page 24

Share: